Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Scott Mitchell
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
REALTOR®
(917) 297-5947

61 N Cartwright Road , Shelter Island, NY 11964

Sold: $2,175,000
Sold on: Nov 16th, 2026
$ Per Square Foot: $667
Sold: $2,175,000
Sold on: Nov 16th, 2026
$ Per Square Foot: $667
BEDS5 BATHS4 full SQUARE FEET3,262 MLS#1058792
STATUSClosed PROPERTY TYPEResidential - Single Family SCHOOLShelter Island


Property Description

Set on a well-proportioned acre in one of Shelter Islands most sought-after neighborhoods, this 1850s farmhouse offers charm, generous living space, and an exceptional location, with room for a pool. The main level features a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a dining room with a second wood-burning fireplace, and a bright sunroom. The open kitchen offers two exterior doors leading to side porches, providing an inviting connection to the outdoors and an ideal setting for entertaining. Upstairs are five generously sized bedrooms and three full bathrooms. A full basement and attic provide ample storage and utility space. Just a stones throw from Coecles Harbor Marina, this property presents an opportunity to enjoy the tranquility of Shelter Island.

Property Features

Basement: Yes
Basement: Full, Partially Finished, Walk-Out Access
Cooling: Wall/Window Unit(s)
Days on Market: 39
Fireplaces: 2
Garage: 1
Heating: Baseboard, Hot Water, Propane
Lot Size: 1.00 Acres
Taxes: $7,579
Year Built: 1858

Amenities

First Floor Full Bath
Eat-in Kitchen
Formal Dining

Feature Descriptions

Appliances: Dishwasher, Exhaust Fan, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Attic: Full
Building Area Total: 3262
Exterior: HardiPlank Type
Fireplace Features: Wood Burning
Fireplace Y/N: Yes
Flooring: Wood
Formal Dining: Yes
GarageY/N: Yes
Heating Zones: 6
On Market Date: 2026-10-08
Parcel Number: 0700-008-00-03-00-048-000
Parking Features: Driveway, Garage
Rental Term: Monthly
Rooms Total: 9
Sewer: Septic Tank
Utilities: Cable Available, Electricity Available, Propane, Water Connected
Water: Well
Window Features: Shutters, Storm Window(s)

Local Schools

High School: Shelter Island School
Middle School: Shelter Island School
Elementary School: Shelter Island School
School District: Shelter Island

Listed By / Sold By

Listed By

Agency Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Agency Phone: 631-749-1155

Shown By

Agent Name: Scott Mitchell
Agent Phone: (917) 297-5947
Agency Title: Laffey Real Estate

Sold By

Agency Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Agency Phone: 631-749-1155
Agent Name: Tina Marika Kaasik

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 11/19/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 11/19/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Thu 11/19/2026 12:08:38 AM EST) or OneKey MLS (last updated Thu 11/19/2026 12:00:21 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Laffey Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.

Listing data and photos distributed by MLSGRID
Member Participants (and their affiliated licensees, if applicable) shall indicate on their websites that IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID, and that the use of the MLS GRID Data may be subject to an end user license agreement prescribed by the Member Participant’s applicable MLS if any and as amended from time to time. MLS GRID may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Member Participant, and/or their MLS from liability.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.



Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Login to My Homefinder